Srimad-Bhagavatam: Canto 7: “The Science of God”
by His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada
Chapter Two
SB7.2.16
TEXT 16
evam viprakrte loke
daityendranucarair muhuh
divam devah parityajya
bhuvi cerur alaksitah
SYNONYMS
evam—thus; viprakrte—being disturbed; loke—when all the people; daitya-indra-anucaraih—by the followers of Hiranyakasipu, the King of the Daityas; muhuh—again and again; divam—the heavenly planets; devah—the demigods; parityajya—giving up; bhuvi—on the planet earth; ceruh—wandered (to see the extent of the disturbances); alaksitah—unseen by the demons.
TRANSLATION
Thus disturbed again and again by the unnatural occurrences caused by the followers of Hiranyakasipu, all the people had to cease the activities of Vedic culture. Not receiving the results of yajna, the demigods also became disturbed. They left their residential quarters in the heavenly planets and, unobserved by the demons, began wandering on the planet earth to see the disasters.
PURPORT
As stated in Bhagavad-gita, the performance of yajna brings reciprocal good fortune for both the human beings and the demigods. When the performances of yajna were stopped by the disturbances of the demons, the demigods were naturally bereft of the results of yajna and hampered in executing their respective duties. Therefore they came down to the planet earth to see how people had become disturbed and to consider what to do. SB7.2.17 TEXT 17 hiranyakasipur bhratuh samparetasya duhkhitah krtva katodakadini bhratr-putran asantvayat SYNONYMS hiranyakasipuh—Hiranyakasipu; bhratuh—of the brother; samparetasya—deceased; duhkhitah—being very much distressed; krtva—performing; katodaka-adini—ceremonies observed after a death; bhratr-putran—the sons of his brother; asantvayat—pacified. TRANSLATION After performing the ritualistic observances for the death of his brother, Hiranyakasipu, being extremely unhappy, tried to pacify his nephews. SB7.2.18-19 TEXTS 18–19 sakunim sambaram dhrstim bhutasantapanam vrkam kalanabham mahanabham harismasrum athotkacam tan-mataram rusabhanum ditim ca jananim gira slaksnaya desa-kala-jna idam aha janesvara SYNONYMS sakunim—Sakuni; sambaram—Sambara; dhrstim—Dhrsti; bhutasantapanam—Bhutasantapana; vrkam—Vrka; kalanabham—Kalanabha; mahanabham—Mahanabha; harismasrum—Harismasru; atha—as well as; utkacam—Utkaca; tat-mataram—their mother; rusabhanum—Rusabhanu; ditim—Diti; ca—and; jananim—his own mother; gira—by words; slaksnaya—very sweet; desa-kala-jnah—who was expert in understanding the time and situation; idam—this; aha—said; jana-isvara—O King. TRANSLATION O King, Hiranyakasipu was extremely angry, but since he was a great politician, he knew how to act according to the time and situation. With sweet words he began pacifying his nephews, whose names were Sakuni, Sambara, Dhrsti, Bhutasantapana, Vrka, Kalanabha, Mahanabha, Harismasru and Utkaca. He also consoled their mother, his sister-in-law, Rusabhanu, as well as his own mother, Diti. He spoke to them all as follows. SB7.2.20 TEXT 20 sri-hiranyakasipur uvaca ambamba he vadhuh putra viram marhatha socitum ripor abhimukhe slaghyah suranam vadha ipsitah SYNONYMS sri-hiranyakasipuh uvaca—Hiranyakasipu said; amba amba—my mother, my mother; he—O; vadhuh—my sister-in-law; putrah—O sons of my brother; viram—the hero; ma—not; arhatha—you deserve; socitum—to lament about; ripoh—of the enemy; abhimukhe—in front; slaghyah—glorious; suranam—of those who are actually great; vadhah—killing; ipsitah—desired. TRANSLATION Hiranyakasipu said: My dear mother, sister-in-law and nephews, you should not lament for the death of the great hero, for a hero’s death in front of his enemy is glorious and desirable. SB7.2.21 TEXT 21 bhutanam iha samvasah prapayam iva suvrate daivenaikatra nitanam unnitanam sva-karmabhih SYNONYMS bhutanam—of all living entities; iha—in this material world; samvasah—the living together; prapayam—in a place for drinking cold water; iva—like; su-vrate—O my gentle mother; daivena—by the superior arrangement; ekatra—in one place; nitanam—of those brought; unnitanam—of those led apart; sva-karmabhih—by their own reactions. TRANSLATION My dear mother, in a restaurant or place for drinking cold water, many travelers are brought together, and after drinking water they continue to their respective destinations. Similarly, living entities join together in a family, and later, as a result of their own actions, they are led apart to their destinations. PURPORT prakrteh kriyamanani “The bewildered soul, under the influence of the three modes of material nature, thinks himself the doer of activities, which are in actuality carried out by nature.” (Bg. 3.27) All living entities act exactly according to the directions of prakrti, material nature, because in the material world we are fully under a higher control. All the living entities in this material world have come here only because they wanted to be equal to Krsna in enjoyment and have thus been sent here to be conditioned by material nature in different degrees. In the material world a so-called family is a combination of several persons in one home to fulfill the terms of their imprisonment. As criminal prisoners scatter as soon as their terms are over and they are released, all of us who have temporarily assembled as family members will continue to our respective destinations. Another example given is that family members are like straws carried together by the waves of a river. Sometimes such straws mix together in whirlpools, and later, dispersed again by the same waves, they float alone in the water. Although Hiranyakasipu was a demon, he had Vedic knowledge and understanding. Thus the advice given to his family members—his sister-in-law, mother and nephews—was quite sound. The demons are considered highly elevated in knowledge, but because they do not use their good intelligence for the service of the Lord, they are called demons. The demigods, however, act very intelligently to satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead. This is confirmed in Srimad-Bhagavatam (1.2.13) as follows: atah pumbhir dvija-srestha “O best among the twice-born, it is therefore concluded that the highest perfection one can achieve, by discharging his prescribed duties [dharma] according to caste divisions and orders of life, is to please the Lord Hari.” To become a demigod or to become godly, whatever one’s occupation, one must satisfy the Supreme Personality of Godhead. SB7.2.22 TEXT 22 nitya atmavyayah suddhah sarvagah sarva-vit parah dhatte ’sav atmano lingam mayaya visrjan gunan SYNONYMS nityah—eternal; atma—spirit soul; avyayah—inexhaustible; suddhah—with no material tinge; sarva-gah—qualified to go anywhere in the material or spiritual worlds; sarva-vit—full of knowledge; parah—transcendental to material conditions; dhatte—accepts; asau—that atma, or living being; atmanah—of the self; lingam—a body; mayaya—by the material energy; visrjan—creating; gunan—various material qualities. TRANSLATION The spirit soul, the living entity, has no death, for he is eternal and inexhaustible. Being free from material contamination, he can go anywhere in the material or spiritual worlds. He is fully aware and completely different from the material body, but because of being misled by misuse of his slight independence, he is obliged to accept subtle and gross bodies created by the material energy and thus be subjected to so-called material happiness and distress. Therefore, no one should lament for the passing of the spirit soul from the body. PURPORT Hiranyakasipu very intelligently described the position of the soul. The soul is never the body, but is always completely different from the body. Being eternal and inexhaustible, the soul has no death, but when the same pure soul desires to enjoy the material world independently, he is placed under the conditions of material nature and must therefore accept a certain type of body and suffer the pains and pleasures thereof. This is also described by Krsna in Bhagavad-gita (13.22). Karanam guna-sango ’sya sad-asad-yoni janmasu: the living entity is born in different families or species of life because of being infected by the modes of material nature. When conditioned by material nature, the living entity must accept a certain type of body, which is offered by nature under the direction of the Supreme Lord. isvarah sarva-bhutanam “The Supreme Lord is situated in everyone’s heart, O Arjuna, and is directing the wanderings of all living entities, who are seated as on a machine, made of the material energy.” (Bg. 18.61) The body is just like a machine, and according to the living entity’s karma, he is offered a particular type of machine to move here and there under the control of material nature. This continues until he surrenders to the Supreme Personality of Godhead (mam eva ye prapadyante mayam etam taranti te [Bg. 7.14]). Until he surrenders, the conditioned soul is carried from life to life by the arrangement of material nature. SB7.2.23 TEXT 23 yathambhasa pracalata taravo ’pi cala iva caksusa bhramyamanena drsyate calativa bhuh SYNONYMS yatha—just as; ambhasa—by water; pracalata—moving; taravah—the trees (on the bank of the river); api—also; calah—moving; iva—as if; caksusa—by the eye; bhramyamanena—moving; drsyate—is seen; calati—moving; iva—as if; bhuh—the ground. TRANSLATION Because of the movements of the water, the trees on the bank of a river, when reflected on the water, seem to move. Similarly, when the eyes move because of some mental derangement, the land appears to move also. PURPORT Sometimes, because of mental derangement, the land appears to be moving. A drunkard, for example, or a person with heart disease, sometimes feels that the land is moving. Similarly, the reflections of trees in a flowing river also appear to move. These are the actions of maya. Actually the living entity does not move (sthanur acalo ’yam). The living entity does not take birth or accept death, but because of the transient subtle and gross bodies, the living entity appears to move from one place to another or be dead and gone forever. As the great Bengali Vaisnava poet, Jagadananda Pandita, has said: pisaci paile yena mati-cchanna haya According to this statement from the Prema-vivarta, when a living entity is conditioned by material nature, he is exactly like a person haunted by a ghost. One should therefore understand the fixed position of the spirit soul and how he is carried away by the waves of material nature to different bodies and different situations under lamentation and hankering. One achieves the success of life when he understands the constitutional position of his self and is undisturbed by the conditions created by material nature (prakrteh kriyamanani gunaih karmani sarvasah [Bg. 3.27]). SB7.2.24 TEXT 24 evam gunair bhramyamane manasy avikalah puman yati tat-samyatam bhadre hy alingo lingavan iva SYNONYMS evam—in this way; gunaih—by the modes of material nature; bhramyamane—when shaken; manasi—the mind; avikalah—changeless; puman—the living entity; yati—approaches; tat-samyatam—the same condition of agitation as the mind; bhadre—O my gentle mother; hi—indeed; alingah—without a subtle or gross body; linga-van—possessing a material body; iva—as if. TRANSLATION In the same way, O my gentle mother, when the mind is agitated by the movements of the modes of material nature, the living entity, although freed from all the different phases of the subtle and gross bodies, thinks that he has changed from one condition to another. PURPORT As stated in Srimad-Bhagavatam (10.84.13): yasyatma-buddhih kunape tri-dhatuke “A human being who identifies the body made of three elements as the self, who considers the by-products of the body to be his kinsmen, who considers the land of his birth worshipable, and who goes to a place of pilgrimage simply to bathe rather than to meet men of transcendental knowledge there, is to be considered like a cow or an ass.” Although Hiranyakasipu was a great demon, he was not as foolish as the population of the modern world. Hiranyakasipu had clear knowledge of the spirit soul and the subtle and gross bodies, but now we are so degraded that everyone, including the exalted scientists, philosophers and other leaders, is under the bodily conception of life, which is condemned in the sastras. Sa eva go-kharah: [SB 10.84.13] such persons are nothing but cows and asses. Hiranyakasipu advised his family members that although the gross body of his brother Hiranyaksa was dead and they were aggrieved because of this, they should not lament for the great soul of Hiranyaksa, who had already attained his next destination. Atma, the spirit soul, is always unchanged (avikalah puman). We are spirit souls, but when carried away by mental activities (manodharma), we suffer from so-called material conditions of life. This generally happens to nondevotees. Harav abhaktasya kuto mahad-gunah: nondevotees may possess exalted material qualities, but because they are foolish they have no good qualifications. The designations of the conditioned soul in the material world are decorations of the dead body. The conditioned soul has no information of the spirit and its exalted existence beyond the effects of the material condition. SB7.2.25-26 TEXTS 25–26 esa atma-viparyaso hy alinge linga-bhavana esa priyapriyair yogo viyogah karma-samsrtih sambhavas ca vinasas ca sokas ca vividhah smrtah avivekas ca cinta ca vivekasmrtir eva ca SYNONYMS esah—this; atma-viparyasah—bewilderment of the living being; hi—indeed; alinge—in that which does not possess a material body; linga-bhavana—accepting the material body to be the self; esah—this; priya—with those who are very dear; apriyaih—and with those who are not dear (enemies, those not in the family, etc.); yogah—connection; viyogah—separation; karma—the fruits of action; samsrtih—the material condition of life; sambhavah—accepting birth; ca—and; vinasah—accepting death; ca—and; sokah—lamentation; ca—and; vividhah—varieties; smrtah—mentioned in scripture; avivekah—lack of discrimination; ca—and; cinta—anxiety; ca—also; viveka—of proper discrimination; asmrtih—forgetfulness; eva—indeed; ca—also. TRANSLATION In his bewildered state, the living entity, accepting the body and mind to be the self, considers some people to be his kinsmen and others to be outsiders. Because of this misconception, he suffers. Indeed, the accumulation of such concocted material ideas is the cause of suffering and so-called happiness in the material world. The conditioned soul thus situated must take birth in different species and work in various types of consciousness, thus creating new bodies. This continued material life is called samsara. Birth, death, lamentation, foolishness and anxiety are due to such material considerations. Thus we sometimes come to a proper understanding and sometimes fall again to a wrong conception of life. SB7.2.27 TEXT 27 atrapy udaharantimam itihasam puratanam yamasya preta-bandhunam samvadam tam nibodhata SYNONYMS atra—in this connection; api—indeed; udaharanti—they cite; imam—this; itihasam—history; puratanam—very old; yamasya—of Yamaraja, the superintendent of death, who gives judgment after death; preta-bandhunam—of the friends of a dead man; samvadam—discussion; tam—that; nibodhata—try to understand. TRANSLATION In this regard, an example is given from an old history. This involves a discourse between Yamaraja and the friends of a dead person. Please hear it attentively. PURPORT The words itihasam puratanam mean “an old history.” The Puranas are not chronologically recorded, but the incidents mentioned in the Puranas are actual histories of bygone ages. Srimad-Bhagavatam is the Maha-Purana, the essence of all the Puranas. The Mayavadi scholars do not accept the Puranas, but Srila Madhvacarya and all other authorities accept them as the authoritative histories of the world. SB7.2.28 TEXT 28 usinaresv abhud raja suyajna iti visrutah sapatnair nihato yuddhe jnatayas tam upasata SYNONYMS usinaresu—in the state known as Usinara; abhut—there was; raja—a king; suyajnah—Suyajna; iti—thus; visrutah—celebrated; sapatnaih—by enemies; nihatah—killed; yuddhe—in war; jnatayah—the kinsmen; tam—him; upasata—sat around. TRANSLATION In the state known as Usinara there was a celebrated King named Suyajna. When the King was killed in battle by his enemies, his kinsmen sat down around the dead body and began to lament the death of their friend. SB7.2.29-31 TEXTS 29–31 visirna-ratna-kavacam vibhrastabharana-srajam sara-nirbhinna-hrdayam sayanam asrg-avilam prakirna-kesam dhvastaksam rabhasa dasta-dacchadam rajah-kuntha-mukhambhojam chinnayudha-bhujam mrdhe usinarendram vidhina tatha krtam patim mahisyah prasamiksya duhkhitah hatah sma natheti karair uro bhrsam ghnantyo muhus tat-padayor upapatan SYNONYMS visirna—scattered here and there; ratna—made of jewels; kavacam—protective armor; vibhrasta—fallen off; abharana—ornaments; srajam—garlands; sara-nirbhinna—pierced by arrows; hrdayam—the heart; sayanam—lying down; asrk-avilam—smeared with blood; prakirna-kesam—his hair loosened and scattered; dhvasta-aksam—his eyes obscured; rabhasa—with anger; dasta—bitten; dacchadam—his lips; rajah-kuntha—covered with dust; mukha-ambhojam—his face, which had formerly resembled a lotus flower; chinna—cut off; ayudha-bhujam—his arms and weapons; mrdhe—on the battlefield; usinara-indram—the master of the state of Usinara; vidhina—by providence; tatha—thus; krtam—forced into this position; patim—the husband; mahisyah—the queens; prasamiksya—seeing; duhkhitah—very much aggrieved; hatah—killed; sma—certainly; natha—O husband; iti—thus; karaih—with the hands; urah—the breast; bhrsam—constantly; ghnantyah—pounding; muhuh—again and again; tat-padayoh—at the feet of the King; upapatan—fell down. TRANSLATION His golden, bejeweled armor smashed, his ornaments and garlands fallen from their places, his hair scattered and his eyes lusterless, the slain King lay on the battlefield, his entire body smeared with blood, his heart pierced by the arrows of the enemy. When he died he had wanted to show his prowess, and thus he had bitten his lips, and his teeth remained in that position. His beautiful lotuslike face was now black and covered with dust from the battlefield. His arms, with his sword and other weapons, were cut and broken. When the queens of the King of Usinara saw their husband lying in that position, they began crying, “O lord, now that you have been killed, we also have been killed.” Repeating these words again and again, they fell down, pounding their breasts, at the feet of the dead King. PURPORT As stated here, rabhasa dasta-dacchadam: the dead King, while fighting in anger, bit his lips to show his prowess, but nonetheless he was killed by providence (vidhina). This proves that we are controlled by higher authorities; our personal power or endeavor is not always supreme. We must therefore accept the position offered to us by the order of the Supreme. SB7.2.32 TEXT 32 rudatya uccair dayitanghri-pankajam sincantya asraih kuca-kunkumarunaih visrasta-kesabharanah sucam nrnam srjantya akrandanaya vilepire SYNONYMS rudatyah—crying; uccaih—very loudly; dayita—of their beloved husband; anghri-pankajam—the lotus feet; sincantyah—moistening; asraih—with tears; kuca-kunkuma-arunaih—which were red from the kunkuma covering their breasts; visrasta—scattered; kesa—hair; abharanah—and ornaments; sucam—grief; nrnam—of the people in general; srjantyah—creating; akrandanaya—by crying very pitiably; vilepire—began to lament. TRANSLATION As the queens loudly cried, their tears glided down their breasts, becoming reddened by kunkuma powder, and fell upon the lotus feet of their husband. Their hair became disarrayed, their ornaments fell, and in a way that evoked sympathy from the hearts of others, the queens began lamenting their husband’s death. SB7.2.33 TEXT 33 aho vidhatrakarunena nah prabho bhavan pranito drg-agocaram dasam usinaranam asi vrttidah pura krto ’dhuna yena sucam vivardhanah SYNONYMS aho—alas; vidhatra—by providence; akarunena—who is merciless; nah—our; prabho—O lord; bhavan—Your Lordship; pranitah—taken away; drk—of sight; agocaram—beyond the range; dasam—to a state; usinaranam—to the inhabitants of the state of Usinara; asi—you were; vrtti-dah—giving livelihood; pura—formerly; krtah—finished; adhuna—now; yena—by whom; sucam—of lamentation; vivardhanah—increasing. TRANSLATION O lord, you have now been removed by cruel providence to a state beyond our sight. You had previously sustained the livelihood of the inhabitants of Usinara, and thus they were happy, but your condition now is the cause of their unhappiness. SB7.2.34 TEXT 34 tvaya krtajnena vayam mahi-pate katham vina syama suhrttamena te tatranuyanam tava vira padayoh susrusatinam disa yatra yasyasi SYNONYMS tvaya—you; krtajnena—a most grateful personality; vayam—we; mahi-pate—O King; katham—how; vina—without; syama—shall exist; suhrt-tamena—the best of our friends; te—of you; tatra—there; anuyanam—the following; tava—of you; vira—O hero; padayoh—of the lotus feet; susrusatinam—of those engaging in the service; disa—please order; yatra—where; yasyasi—you will go. TRANSLATION O King, O hero, you were a very grateful husband and the most sincere friend of all of us. How shall we exist without you? O hero, wherever you are going, please direct us there so that we may follow in your footsteps and engage again in your service. Let us go along with you! PURPORT Formerly, a ksatriya king was generally the husband of many wives, and after the death of the king, especially in the battlefield, all the queens would agree to accept saha-marana, dying with the husband who was their life. When Pandu Maharaja, the father of the Pandavas, died, his two wives—namely, the mother of Yudhisthira, Bhima and Arjuna and the mother of Nakula and Sahadeva—were both ready to die in the fire with their husband. Later, after a compromise was arranged, Kunti stayed alive to care for the little children, and the other wife, Madri, was allowed to die with her husband. This system of saha-marana continued in India even until the time of British rule, but later it was discouraged, since the attitude of wives gradually changed with the advancement of Kali-yuga. Thus the system of saha-marana has practically been abolished. Nevertheless, within the past fifty years I have seen the wife of a medical practitioner voluntarily accept death immediately when her husband died. Both the husband and wife were taken in procession in the mourning cart. Such intense love of a chaste wife for her husband is a special case. SB7.2.35 TEXT 35 evam vilapatinam vai parigrhya mrtam patim anicchatinam nirharam arko ’stam sannyavartata SYNONYMS evam—thus; vilapatinam—of the lamenting queens; vai—indeed; parigrhya—taking on their laps; mrtam—the dead; patim—husband; anicchatinam—not desiring; nirharam—the carrying out of the body for the funeral ceremony; arkah—the sun; astam—the setting position; sannyavartata—passed away. TRANSLATION The time was appropriate for the body to be burned, but the queens, not allowing it to be taken away, continued lamenting for the dead body, which they kept on their laps. In the meantime, the sun completed its movements for setting in the west. PURPORT According to the Vedic system, if a person dies during the daytime it is customary for his funeral ceremony to be performed before the sun sets, regardless of whether he is burned or buried, and if he dies at night the funeral must be completed before the next sunrise. Apparently the queens continued lamenting for the dead body, the lump of matter, and would not allow it to be taken away for burning. This illustrates the strong grip of illusion among foolish persons who consider the body the self. Women are generally considered less intelligent. Because of ignorance only, the queens thought of the dead body as their husband and somehow or other thought that if the body were kept their husband would remain with them. Such a conception of the self is certainly for go-khara—cows and asses. We have actually seen that sometimes when a cow’s calf has died the milkman cheats the cow by presenting before her the dead body of her calf. Thus the cow, who would not otherwise allow milking, licks the dead body of the calf and allows herself to be milked. This substantiates the description of the sastra that a foolish man in the bodily concept of life is like a cow. Not only do foolish men and women consider the body the self, but we have even seen that the dead body of a so-called yogi was kept for days by his disciples, who thought that their guru was in samadhi. When decomposition began and a bad smell unfortunately began to overwhelm the yogic power, the disciples allowed the dead body of the so-called yogi to be burned. Thus the bodily concept of life is extremely strong among foolish persons, who are compared to cows and asses. Nowadays, great scientists are trying to freeze dead bodies so that in the future these frozen bodies may again be brought to life. The incident narrated by Hiranyakasipu from history must have taken place millions of years ago because Hiranyakasipu lived millions of years ago and was even then quoting from history. Thus the incident occurred before Hiranyakasipu’s lifetime, but the same ignorance in the bodily concept of life is still prevalent, not only among laymen but even among scientists who think they will be able to revive frozen corpses. Apparently the queens did not want to deliver the dead body for burning because they were afraid of dying with the dead body of their husband. SB7.2.36 TEXT 36 tatra ha preta-bandhunam asrutya paridevitam aha tan balako bhutva yamah svayam upagatah SYNONYMS tatra—there; ha—certainly; preta-bandhunam—of the friends and relatives of the dead King; asrutya—hearing; paridevitam—the loud lamentation (so loud that it could be heard from the planet of Yamaraja); aha—said; tan—unto them (the lamenting queens); balakah—a boy; bhutva—becoming; yamah—Yamaraja, the superintendent of death; svayam—personally; upagatah—after coming. TRANSLATION While the queens were lamenting for the dead body of the King, their loud cries were heard even from the abode of Yamaraja. Assuming the body of a boy, Yamaraja personally approached the relatives of the dead body and advised them as follows. PURPORT Sometimes the living entity is forced to give up his body and enter another one according to the judgment of Yamaraja. It is difficult, however, for the conditioned soul to enter another body unless the present dead body is annihilated through cremation or some other means. The living being has attachment for the present body and does not want to enter another, and thus in the interim he remains a ghost. If a living being who has already left his body has been pious, Yamaraja, just to give him relief, will give him another body. Since the living being in the body of the King had some attachment to his body, he was hovering as a ghost, and therefore Yamaraja, as a special consideration, approached the lamenting relatives to instruct them personally. Yamaraja approached them as a child because a child is not restricted but is granted admittance anywhere, even to the palace of a king. Besides this, the child was speaking philosophy. People are very much interested in hearing philosophy when it is spoken by a child. SB7.2.37 TEXT 37 sri-yama uvaca aho amisam vayasadhikanam vipasyatam loka-vidhim vimohah yatragatas tatra gatam manusyam svayam sadharma api socanty apartham SYNONYMS sri-yamah uvaca—Sri Yamaraja said; aho—alas; amisam—of these; vayasa—by age; adhikanam—of those advanced; vipasyatam—seeing every day; loka-vidhim—the law of nature (that everyone dies); vimohah—the bewilderment; yatra—from where; agatah—came; tatra—there; gatam—returned; manusyam—the man; svayam—themselves; sa-dharmah—similar in nature (prone to die); api—although; socanti—they lament; apartham—uselessly. TRANSLATION Sri Yamaraja said: Alas, how amazing it is! These persons, who are older than me, have full experience that hundreds and thousands of living entities have taken birth and died. Thus they should understand that they also are apt to die, yet still they are bewildered. The conditioned soul comes from an unknown place and returns after death to that same unknown place. There is no exception to this rule, which is conducted by material nature. Knowing this, why do they uselessly lament? PURPORT The Lord says in Bhagavad-gita (2.28): avyaktadini bhutani “All created beings are unmanifest in their beginning, manifest in their interim state, and unmanifest again when they are annihilated. So what need is there for lamentation?” Accepting that there are two classes of philosophers, one believing in the existence of the soul and the other not believing in its existence, there is no cause for lamentation in either case. Nonbelievers in the existence of the soul are called atheists by followers of Vedic wisdom. Yet even if for argument’s sake we accept the atheistic theory, there is still no cause for lamentation. Apart from the separate existence of the soul, the material elements remain unmanifested before creation. From this subtle state of unmanifestation comes manifestation, just as from ether, air is generated; from air, fire is generated; from fire, water is generated; and from water, earth becomes manifested. From the earth, many varieties of manifestations take place. For example, a big skyscraper is manifested from the earth. When it is dismantled, the manifestation becomes again unmanifested and remains as atoms in the ultimate stage. The law of conservation of energy remains, but in the course of time things are manifested and unmanifested—that is the difference. Then what cause is there for lamentation, in either manifestation or unmanifestation? Somehow or other, even in the unmanifested stage, things are not lost. Both at the beginning and at the end, all elements remain unmanifested, and this does not make any real material difference. If we accept the Vedic conclusion as stated in the Bhagavad-gita (antavanta ime dehah) that these material bodies are perishable in due course of time (nityasyoktah saririnah) but that the soul is eternal, then we must remember always that the body is like a dress; therefore why lament the changing of a dress? The material body has no factual existence in relation to the eternal soul. It is something like a dream. In a dream we may think of flying in the sky or sitting on a chariot as a king, but when we wake up we can see that we are neither in the sky nor seated on the chariot. The Vedic wisdom encourages self-realization on the basis of the nonexistence of the material body. Therefore, in either case, whether one believes in the existence of the soul or one does not believe in the existence of the soul, there is no cause for lamentation for loss of the body. In the Mahabharata it is said, adarsanad ihayatah punas cadarsanam gatah. This statement could support the theory of the atheistic scientist that the child in the womb of the mother has no life but is simply a lump of matter. To follow this theory, if the lump of matter is aborted by a surgical operation, no life is killed; the body of a child is like a tumor, and if a tumor is operated upon and thrown away, no sin is involved. The same argument could be put forward in regard to the King and his queens. The body of the King was manifested from an unmanifested source, and again it became unmanifested from manifestation. Since the manifestation exists only in the middle—between the two points of unmanifestation—why should one cry for the body manifested in the interim?
gunaih karmani sarvasah
ahankara-vimudhatma
kartaham iti manyate
varnasrama-vibhagasah
svanusthitasya dharmasya
samsiddhir hari-tosanam
hrd-dese ’rjuna tisthati
bhramayan sarva-bhutani
yantrarudhani mayaya
maya-grasta jivera haya se bhava udaya
sva-dhih kalatradisu bhauma-ijya-dhih
yat-tirtha-buddhih salile na karhicij
janesv abhijnesu sa eva go-kharah
vyakta-madhyani bharata
avyakta-nidhanany eva
tatra ka paridevana